Carolina Panthers Retrospective

Poll

What should be done with Delhomme?

Benched
26% - 6
Benched and cut
8% - 2
Given one more game to redeem himself
43% - 10
Start the full season and decide after the season
21% - 5

Total : 23

Poll created on: Sep-15-09 12:07:52:am

jayj6
Your words are my weapon.
useravatar
User Info

What should we do with JD?

Please take time and actually think about this.  And understand what the implications of your choice mean also.  Like benching and who would play.  Discuss your choice and explain why and what you think should happen in the aftermath of your choice.


For me I will give him one game.  I personally think maybe his surgery did not take and with the pressure the OL failed to prevent I would like to see one more try.  If for nothing else bc of what he has done for us in the past and yes that is a little homerism and living in the past but I believe in gratitude call me crazy.

That is mine what is your opinion?  PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE TAKE YOUR TIME TO THINK ABOUT IT.

Administrator has disabled public posting
J Thomas
Wanted : New Scouting Dept.
useravatar
User Info

Re: What should we do with JD?

Put him out to pasture with his horses!

Administrator has disabled public posting
jayj6
Your words are my weapon.
useravatar
User Info

Re: What should we do with JD?

I forgot to add what I would like to see happen.  If he even does poorer than Ryan in this very important game I say get rid of him.  We need this game more than ever right now.  He better light it on fire.  If not I say bench and cut him bc we can not have him on the roster if we want a young guy to step up.  I think he would be professional but I do not think Moore or Cantwell could be the guy if he was still there mentally.

Administrator has disabled public posting
StillNotKyle
Captain Awesome
useravatar
User Info

Re: What should we do with JD?

You know what? I spent the entire offseason defending this guy.

I bought his authentic (read:EXPENSIVE) jersey.
His signed poster is here hanging in my dorm.
His hideously deformed bobblehead stares at me creepily while I sleep.

So you can understand that I can say this with absolutely no bias:

If he throws for any less than 200 yards, or any more than 2 INTS, John Fox had better make for damn sure that he rides the pine.

Administrator has disabled public posting
BD
useravatar
User Info

Re: What should we do with JD?

I say 1 more game but if he really sucks this game I say bench him--I would really love to see fox run the ball a lot and pass very little with some PA involved--try to build up a little confidence in him, I know Fox and I know he'll stick with Jack for as long as he is healthy though


Administrator has disabled public posting
jayj6
Your words are my weapon.
useravatar
User Info

Re: What should we do with JD?

And start who?  And when I asks that it is not a cloaked "we have to keep JD bc we have no one else" attempt.  I am really want to know who we should start.  I say either a young guy or keep him until the end of the season.  If it is not an investment in the future then I am uninterested IMO.  I am seriously for either Cantwell or Moore.

Administrator has disabled public posting
Hook
useravatar
User Info

Re: What should we do with JD?

I say bench him.  I would make Moore the starter for the rest of the season.  Give Moore all the advantages Jake has had.  If he is not ready in his 3rd season to take over and get better with experience then Moore is not the answer either and we should cut him.  A third year guy should be ready to be trusted.  If he is not then the coaches are to blame.  Moore has probably gotten very few reps with the starters .  Give him all the first team reps for several weeks in a row and lets see what we have.  He can't do worse.  My guess is this is the worst back to back games ever played by a QB in the history of the league.  If Moore is not ready to play I think you have to question all the team personnel in charge of his development...what the hell have they been doing for 3 years.  If I had my say Fox would have to start Moore and he would have to play at least average or I would start cleaning house.  You don't spend 3 yrs developing a QB to suck.  I fear our QB coaching stunk before and still stinks.


Administrator has disabled public posting

Board Info

Board Stats:   Total Users: 816  Total Topics: 2266  Total Polls: 26  Total Posts: 23498  Dormant
User Info:   Newest User :  Imarckr2   Members Online: 0   Guests Online: 136
Online  There are no members online
Topic
New
Locked
Topic
New
Locked
Sticky
Active
New/Active
Sticky
Active
New/Active
New/Closed
New Sticky
Closed/Active
New/Locked
New Sticky
Locked/Active
Active/Sticky
Sticky/Locked
Sticky Active Locked
Active/Sticky
Sticky/Locked
Sticky/Active/Locked